AVI GLOBAL TRUST
PLC
Monthly Update
AVI Global Trust plc (the "Company")
presents its Update, reporting performance figures for the month
ended 31 January
2025.
This Monthly Newsletter is available
on the Company's website at:
AGT-JANUARY-2025.pdf
This investment management report
relates to performance figures to 31 December 2024.
Total
Return (£)
|
Month
|
Calendar Yr
to date
|
1Y
|
3Y
|
5Y
|
10Y
|
AGT NAV
|
0.7%
|
0.7%
|
9.8%
|
27.3%
|
71.4%
|
172.0%
|
MSCI ACWI
|
4.2%
|
4.2%
|
23.7%
|
37.6%
|
79.1%
|
206.9%
|
MSCI ACWI ex US
|
4.9%
|
4.9%
|
13.6%
|
19.5%
|
38.7%
|
101.3%
|
Manager's Comment
AVI
Global Trust (AGT)'s NAV increased +0.7% in
January.
Aker, Reckitt and TSI Holdings were
the largest positive contributors adding +44bps, +42bps and +25bps
apiece.
At the other end of the table,
Softbank detracted -78bps, followed by Chrysalis and Cordiant
Digital which detracted - 34bps and -29bps,
respectively.
Japan
Like many so-called value investors,
Japan has always been a market that has fascinated us.
As long-term readers of our letters
will know, in 2017 we became especially excited about Japan,
increasing our exposure to 16% of NAV and writing in the
June 2017 newsletter:
"Japan has long been a market with a glut of value
opportunities, but we are now seeing genuine and tangible changes
in attitudes from management and boards towards corporate
governance and capital allocation."
At the time this was a contrarian
call, with Japan seen by many as an irrelevant backwater for global
equity investors.
Since this point we have had a
significant portion of our NAV invested in Japan and demonstrated
an ability to generate attractive returns through our constructive
approach to activism. Since 2017, this had added +21% to AGT's NAV
(£) and we have generated a JPY total return of +82%, versus +75%
and +99% for the MSCI Japan Small and TOPIX, respectively
(JPY).
Over the last eight years, the
weight of evidence that Japan is changing has grown. We previously
described 2023 as a seminal year in which global investors, spurred
on by the efforts of the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) and its
attempts to address the issues of companies trading below book
value, woke up and smelt the coffee. Japanese equities have gained
global relevance once again.
As we have learnt over time, the
path to progress can be frustratingly slow at times, and it is not
always linear with steps back along the way. With that said, as we
survey the landscape in 2025, we are as optimistic as we have ever
been.
Private equity interest in Japan has
been brewing for some time and the recent battle between KKR and
Bain for Fuji Soft exemplifies the growing market for corporate
control. Importantly, and in many ways connected to this, we are
seeing management teams become increasingly active in their
attempts to boost and unlock corporate value. As active engaged
owners, these are two attractive forces to have moving in the right
direction.
TSI Holdings (1.0% weight), the
diversified apparel holding company in which AVI owns an 8% stake
across its funds, is indicative of the attractive opportunities we
find in Japan. The core apparel business is of decent quality, but
with significant self-help measures required to boost margins.
Beneath the surface, lies considerable hidden asset value
exemplified by an announcement in January of the sale of non-core
property assets totalling 30% of the company's market cap. This
helped the shares rise +17% over the month, adding +25bps to AGT's
NAV. In a little under two years the position has now generated a
return of +95% and an IRR of 56% (both in JPY).
Over the last month we have been
adding to both new and existing names, such that Japan now accounts
for 22% of NAV (excluding the hedged position in Softbank Group).
We would expect this pattern to continue and find it interesting
that trends toward improved governance and increased levels of
corporate activity can be found in both small and large caps. From
both a valuation and catalyst perspective, we believe Japan stacks
up as being highly attractive, and this is reflected in our
portfolio positioning.
Net
Lease Office Properties (NLOP)
We are typically not interested in
owning businesses or assets in troubled or distressed sectors. As
we often say, we want to own durable businesses that are growing in
value. For long-term holdings we want the compounding of NAV to
work in our favour. This is evident in our largest look-through
holdings - such as Belron, Universal Music Group and REA. These
businesses exhibit distinct competitive advantages, with healthy
organic growth prospects, margins and returns on
capital.
With that said, we try and remain
pragmatic in identifying situations where discounted valuations are
likely to arise, and where there are specific catalysts to narrow
discounts. In our experience spin-offs can often lead to mispricing
and this is particularly true in the case of out of favour assets,
where natural buying interest is limited. In-turn we also have
experience of investing in portfolios of assets in run-off /
liquidation, which acts as a pull to par as the NAV is
realised.
Net Lease Office Properties ("NLOP")
is a $467m US listed office REIT which ticks both these boxes and
is currently a 1.2% weight in the portfolio.
NLOP was spun out of its parent
company W.P. Carey, the global net lease REIT, in 2023 with the
sole aim to wind down the portfolio and return cash to
shareholders. At the outset, NLOP consisted of an office portfolio
of 59 assets, totalling 8.7msqft of leasable space. From the
perspective of W.P. Carey this hived off its office portfolio
which, given widespread and well understood concerns about the
asset class, had acted as a drag on valuation.
The spin dynamics and out-of-favour
nature of the asset class allowed us to build a position in
mid-2024 at a more than 40% discount to our estimated NAV and a 16%
implied cap rate. The valuation corresponded to c.$95 per square
foot, which compared favourably to the $163psf valuation at which
JP Morgan provided debt financing on the portfolio.
The investment case was not
predicated on some great revival of the asset class, but rather the
market's pessimistic implied valuations and the prospect for the
wind down to realise value.
Progress here has been promising. In
January NLOP announced the sale of five properties, generating
gross proceeds of $43m, with proceeds over the last twelve months
amounting to $364m as the portfolio has reduced from 59 properties
at listing to 39 currently. Sales over 2024 occurred at a cap rate
of 10.5%, versus the market's current implied c.15%. Importantly,
the latest transaction included both a vacant property (Eagan, MN
previously let to BCBSM) and a property with less than a year left
on the lease (let to Cofinity), thereby negating any accusation of
cherry picking.
Moreover, in conjunction with funds
from rental operations, these asset sales have allowed for the full
repayment of JP Morgan's senior secured mortgage and leave $61m
outstanding on its mezzanine loan (in addition to $110m of recourse
debt). Under the financing agreements, proceeds from asset sales
had to be used to repay these secured loans. However, as we near
the point where these loans are repaid, we believe capital will
start to be returned to shareholders later this year, expediting
returns to shareholders. On our estimates we believe upside from
here is north of 50%.
Contributors / Detractors (in GBP)
Largest Contributors
|
1- month
contribution
bps
|
% Weight
|
Aker ASA
|
44
|
4.0
|
Reckitt Benckiser
|
42
|
4.2
|
TSI Holdings
|
25
|
1.0
|
Christian Dior
|
25
|
3.0
|
News Corp
|
24
|
7.3
|
Largest Detractors
|
1- month
contribution
bps
|
% Weight
|
SoftBank Group
|
-78
|
5.6
|
Chrysalis Investments
|
-34
|
7.1
|
Cordiant Digital
Infrastructure
|
-29
|
4.0
|
Rohto Pharmaceutical
|
-24
|
3.7
|
Partners Group PE
|
-20
|
4.9
|
MUFG Corporate Governance Limited
Corporate Secretary
07 February 2025
LEI: 213800QUODCLWWRVI968
The content of the Company's
web-pages and the content of any website or pages which may be
accessed through hyperlinks on the Company's web-pages, other than
the content of the Newsletter referred to above, is neither
incorporated into nor forms part of the above
announcement.