Off-Balance-Sheet Rules Could Weigh On Banks' Capital
22 Maggio 2009 - 10:48PM
Dow Jones News
A freshly minted accounting rule will simplify the largest
banks' balance sheets by early next year.
Getting them through the clean-up process, however, will require
some finesse from regulators.
Earlier this week, the Financial Accounting Standards Board,
which sets U.S. accounting rules, ordered banks to consolidate
their so-called off-balance-sheet entities by the first quarter of
2010. The transparency-minded moves will do away with a boom-time
practice that helped financial firms increase their operating
leverage.
The new rules will also undoubtedly chip away at the capital
levels of Bank of America Corp. (BAC), Citigroup Inc. (C), JPMorgan
Chase & Co. (JPM) and Wells Fargo & Co. (WFC). The
government's recently completed stress test of banks reportedly
factored in banks' off-balance-sheet exposures, but regulators may
have to accommodate the new dictates by ratcheting up related
capital requirements for banks slowly over time.
"The regulators do not want an accounting change to suddenly
negatively affect the banks' capital ratios," said Bimal Shah, an
analyst at Fox-Pitt Kelton. He said regulators are still
deliberating the specifics of how to tell banks to apply the
rules.
According to a report from Shah on Friday, Bank of America's
tangible common equity ratio would fall in the first quarter of
2010 to 3.1%, as measured against tangible assets, from a projected
3.8% once the firm consolidates its off-balance-sheet exposure.
Wells Fargo's would fall to 3.72% from 4.41%, and JPMorgan's would
fall to 3.95% from 4.40%.
In normal times, firms typically have TCE ratios of 5% to 6% or
more. Low TCE ratios can be a warning that a firm will have to
raise capital, which can dilute existing shareholders.
Off-balance-sheet entities are something of a relic from the
recent credit boom, when large banks wrote loans and sold them off
to investors in soaring volumes, earning hefty fees in the process.
Banks used a host of methods to turn loans over quickly, and
creating off-balance-sheet entities was one of them.
Banks typically sold an array of loans to these arcane entities
- which will become extinct under the new rules - and the entities
typically issued commercial debt to fund the purchase. Banks could
argue that they had sold off the loans and therefore didn't need to
hold capital against them, as banks have to do with conventional
loans in case they become delinquent.
As the credit crisis peaked, however, it became clear to
investors and depositors that banks were in fact exposed to losses
from loans they'd technically sold to off-balance-sheet entities.
In many cases, for example, banks agreed to guarantee the
performance of the sold loans, which means they'd be forced to
repurchase bad loans if too much of the debt they had sold turned
sour.
The fuzzy nature of these relationships, which banks thinly
disclose through filings, makes it difficult for investors to
assess how much off-balance-sheet risk each large bank is exposed
to. The new accounting rule will likely make those exposures
clearer to investors in the future.
"It certainly sounds like we'll have more transparency," said
Anthony Polini, an analyst at Raymond James Financial Inc.
State Street Corp. (STT) was rocked early this year when it was
forced to step in and support more than $20 billion in
off-balance-sheet assets. The firm addressed the lingering issue
Monday, when it raised capital and took the assets onto its balance
sheet ahead of the Dec. 31 deadline.
-By Marshall Eckblad, Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-4306;
marshall.eckblad@dowjones.com