Ameriprise's RiverSource Raised CIT Stake In 2Q
13 Luglio 2009 - 8:02PM
Dow Jones News
The largest shareholder in troubled CIT Group Inc. (CIT) is a
group of mutual funds run by Ameriprise Financial Inc. (AMP), which
bought nearly all of its 11% stake in the past 10 months.
That Ameriprise subsidiary, RiverSource Investments LLC, bought
12.7 million shares between March 31 and June 30, bringing its
stake to 44.3 million, according to a July 10 regulatory
filing.
RiverSource isn't alone; other institutional holders, according
to regulatory filings in recent months, include Fidelity
Investments, Brandes Investment Partners LP, Vanguard Group and
Wellington Management. Another investor is hedge-fund manager
Edward S. Lampert of ESL Investments, who owns a controlling stake
in Sears Holding Corp. (SHLD). The filings don't disclose more
recent trading, and these investors could have sold CIT shares
since reporting their positions.
At this point, for many investors in CIT, holding on and hoping
for a miracle might be an option. In a sense, the stock, recently
at $1.21 a share, has become a glorified call option; it traded
above $11 as recently as September and above $50 as recently as
July 2007. Some owners may now believe that, with the stock price
so close to $1, the reward of it rising again is a lot greater than
the risk of zero.
As fears grow that business lender CIT might file for bankruptcy
protection, its stock price is plunging, trading down about 20% in
Monday action. The shares are down 73% since Dec. 31, and more than
80% in the past year.
A look at regulatory filings suggests that, compared with some
other institutional investors, RiverSource actually bought on the
low side. A RiverSource portfolio manager didn't return an email
message seeking comment.
The CIT bulls haven't completely disappeared. Standard &
Poor's equity analyst Matthew Albrecht said Monday he's keeping a
"hold" recommendation on the stock, albeit with a lower target
price of $1.50.
"We think the firm could see its approval to issue FDIC-backed
debt granted, may be able to transfer certain assets to its bank
subsidiary with government approval, or may seek to divest assets,
but execution risks remain," Albrecht said in a note.
Lampert's ESL Investments owned 15.4 million CIT shares as of
March 31, according to filings. All of his shares were bought in
2008. CIT shares started 2008 at $24.03, and ended at $4.54.
While RiverSource's 44.3 million shares are as of June 30, many
other institutional holders reported their positions as of the end
of the first quarter, like ESL. Securities and Exchange Commission
rules require certain investors to disclose stock positions within
45 days after the end of a quarter. For holders of 5% or more of
stock, like RiverSource, the rules are more stringent.
Some of CIT's holders have in the past been adept in their
trading of the stock. Fidelity, for one, bought millions of shares
in the $20s earlier this decade, and sold much of it in the $30s
and $40s. Fidelity then got back into the stock in 2008, mostly
when its price was in single digits. Reached for comment, Fidelity
Portfolio Manager Joel Tillinghast referred a reporter to
Fidelity's media relations representative, but said, "I can not add
much value on CIT as its future is in the hands of the
government."
Brandes also showed some adept trading in the stock.
But, according to filings, some other holders like Vanguard have
only on a few occasions lowered their CIT exposure at higher
prices. Many of Vanguard's funds owning CIT shares are index funds
that buy and hold all the stocks in an index. Other index investors
that are sizable owners of CIT shares include Barclays Global
Investors, a unit of Barclays PLC (BCS) being acquired by BlackRock
Inc. (BLK), and State Street Global Advisors, a unit of State
Street Corp. (STT).
-By Joseph Checkler, Dow Jones Newswires; 212-416-2152;
joseph.checkler@dowjones.com